Rumble 19170 Julie James and Sidney Prescott vs. Nancy Thompson and Nancy Wheeler vs. Pumpkinhead and The Creeper (Jeepers Creepers)

[JohnnyChany]

Remote island. The Creeper and Pumpkinhead on the hunt for victims. Two teams of legendary final girls (Team Party of Five and Team Nancy) will fight to survive and escape the island first.

[Callisto]

Learn More About
Sidney Prescott
Read more about Sidney Prescott at Wikipedia
Official Site: Dimension Films Links: Wikipedia Scream Wiki Horror Movies Wiki

Julie James
Read more about Julie James at Wikipedia
Official Site: Columbia Pictures Links: Wikipedia I Know What You Did Last Summer I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

Nancy Thompson
Read more about Nancy Thompson at Wikipedia
Official Site: New Line Cinema Links: Wikipedia NOES wiki Friday the 13th wiki

Nancy Wheeler
Read more about Nancy Wheeler at Wikipedia
Official Site: Netflix Links: Wikipedia

The Creeper (Jeepers Creepers)
Read more about The Creeper (Jeepers Creepers) at Wikipedia
Official Site: MGM Links: Jeepers Creepers Wiki page Imdb Page BeatingU site

Pumpkinhead
Read more about Pumpkinhead at Wikipedia
Official Site: United Artists/MGM Links: Wikipedia Entry IMDB Profile House of Horrors

[Mercenaryblade]

I think team 2 would win, they have more experience with supernatural threats. 

[Boratz]

I'm leaning towards Team 3. The Creeper seems like he would be too fast and deadly for any of them to deal with 

[Pizzaguy2995]

As much as I love Sidney, I think supernatural threats like Creeper and Pumpkin Head might be out of her league.  Team Nancy on the other hand might be able to survive this, they’ve definitely survived more intelligent and deadly killers. 

[Callisto]

MATCH SCORE
Sidney Prescott and Julie James: 0
Nancy Wheeler and Nancy Thompson: 2
The Creeper (Jeepers Creepers) and Pumpkinhead: 2